Dog Charming; Behaviour Consultant & Trainer
0419 905 466
  • Home
  • About
    • Qualifications, Methods & Ethics, Membership
    • Guarantee
  • Behaviour and Training Solutions
    • Initial Consultations/Hourly Rate
    • Puppy Set-Up
    • Discounted Training Package
    • Problem Behaviours
  • Let's Get Started
  • Videos
  • Testimonials
    • Diesel's Behaviour Change Video
    • Dancer's Nail Clipping Video
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Links

To change, or not to change: That is the question.

23/2/2013

12 Comments

 
Change is a part of life, just like choice is a part of life. There are those times when a serious choice might need to be made about whether to change a dog's behaviour.  A dog's behaviour may become incompatible with one's lifestyle or is becoming a welfare problem for the dog or others.  There are various ways to approach this.

* Managing the behaviour - Preventing the dog from being put in a position where the behaviour occurs.  Preventing a behaviour through managing the environment can be very practical.  It can often be less time consuming than modifying behaviour, though still requires planning and diligence. An example is a dog who jumps on visitors being prevented from practising this behaviour by:
a) putting the dog behind a barrier when visitors arrive e.g. a temporary child gate, or
b) placing the dog in another room or outside when visitors come, or
c) tethering the dog inside or keeping the dog on a lead with visitors.

* Ignoring the behaviour -  This can be effective if the behaviour isn't a huge problem or a safety issue.  It does not work effectively with well learned and practised behaviours, those that are self-reinforcing (think barking or toileting) or behaviours associated with fear or anxiety.  Using the same example as above, it would mean letting the dog jump up on visitors, hoping that in the end your dog may eventually "grow out" of the behaviour. If your dog is being reinforced in some way by jumping up on visitors (eye contact, verbal or physical contact), you could be waiting forever!  I prefer not to use this method in isolation.  Giving an alternative behaviour as well as removing reinforcement for the problem behaviour is generally more efficient and less frustrating for both the dog and guardian.

* Changing the Behaviour -  This can be done a number of ways. A very effective method is to provide an alternative behaviour for the dog to do instead of the problem behaviour.  Ensure the problem behaviour no longer receives reinforcement whilst at the same time making sure the replacement behaviour really pays off big time.  For the jumping example, teaching your dog to;
* sit when greeting, or
* keep all four feet on the floor, or
* go to their bed
when visitors arrive works a treat.

The example below shows Zuri in the process of being taught not to jump when greeting visitors.
If you'd like to read more on changing behaviour, Karen Pryor's book, "Don't Shoot the Dog" has a chapter outlining eight methods of getting rid of a behaviour, not limiting examples to dogs.  If you have a messy flat-mate, a spouse who always comes home grumpy or noisy kids driving you crazy in the car, you may find it quite enlightening.

Which method is best for which situation?  Each situation and problem will vary, since each dog and each family varies greatly.  Each choice will be based on a multitude of individual factors. One choice I personally find a no-brainer is the avoidance of punishment as a way of changing behaviour.  Why?  It seldom works. If it does appear to work, it is actually masking its real achievement: suppressing behaviour NOT changing it.  The underlying motivation behind the behaviour is seldom addressed with punishment.  Further, the side effects of punishment are numerous and unpleasant for the subject (that is its modus operandi). When there are effective alternatives, choosing punishment is also unethical.

The decision to modify a behaviour will depend on;

* how important changing behaviour is to the individual and circumstances, 
* whether management and prevention is a feasible option, 
* whether there is a commitment to training through to its fruition and maintenance, and
* whether the subject with the problem behaviour is a realistic candidate for change.  

This is where a professional consultant can help with guidance on what is feasible and what may be in the too-hard-basket.  Some things will require more effort and time than a guardian can commit.  Some things may be unsafe. Some behaviours will have such a strong history or genetic component making them resistant to behaviour change.
Picture
Below is a video example of how Dancer's prey drive and aggressive behaviour was modified using a procedure known as differential reinforcement of an incompatible behaviour.  That simply means, Dancer was trained to do a replacement behaviour that she couldn't perform at the same time as the undesired behaviour.  This also demonstrates the decision making process involved in choosing how to deal with an undesired behaviour.  The first 30 seconds shows the "before" and "after" footage.  The rest of the video details the procedure step-by-step.  Remember, this is a plan devised specifically for this individual.  It is NOT a "how to" video.

The behaviour could have easily been prevented by keeping Dancer inside.  Being out of earshot and sight of the stimulus that caused the reaction would have prevented the behaviour.  

The decision to proceed with a behaviour change plan was made because:

* the guardian had a strong desire to keep her dog with her when she worked out,
* the guardian had a commitment to diligently work on re-training and enjoyed training,
* Dancer already possessed a well trained behaviour that could be used as the replacement behaviour - this would make training quicker,
* Dancer had a solid history of training using positive reinforcement,
* Dancer was a quick and eager learner, and 
* she was extremely food motivated - which all worked in her favour to over-ride her desire to attack the rope.

I think a most satisfactory choice was made for this particular situation :-)

12 Comments
L-A Marcotty
23/2/2013 03:35:17 pm

Another great tutorial, Sonya! Thank you for sharing your excellent work, in such an enjoyable and accessible way.

Reply
Sonya Bevan link
24/2/2013 04:15:10 am

Thanks L-A Marcotty. I'm really pleased you find it enjoyable and appreciate your feedback :-)

Reply
Vikki Pickering link
23/2/2013 11:50:28 pm

Great blog Sonya, nicely written as always! And I really like your example of DRI with Dancer :)

Reply
Sonya Bevan link
24/2/2013 04:17:25 am

Thanks Vikki. I'm so glad you commented. It's one of the greatest compliments to receive acknowledgement from a colleague :-)

Reply
Eileen Anderson link
24/2/2013 03:45:09 am

Oh Sonya, I just love your blogs and videos. My favorite thing on this one (among many) is that you emphasize that changing a behavior is not something to be taken lightly. Such respect for the animals and the people you show. Thanks for sharing this.

Reply
Sonya Bevan link
24/2/2013 04:18:35 am

Thanks Eileen. It's nice to know what particular parts of a blog speak to people.

Reply
Sheila Eaves
24/2/2013 08:37:19 am

Thank you Sonya - most interesting and instructive.

Reply
Sonya Bevan link
24/2/2013 02:40:55 pm

Thanks for letting me know you found it useful, Sheila. Much appreciated.

Reply
like this link
3/2/2014 12:58:34 am

Good post made here. One thing I would like to say is the fact that most professional fields consider the Bachelor Degree as the entry level standard for an online degree. Even though Associate College diplomas are a great way to begin, completing your Bachelors presents you with many doorways to various occupations, there are numerous on-line Bachelor Diploma Programs available by institutions like The University of Phoenix, Intercontinental University Online and Kaplan. Another concern is that many brick and mortar institutions give Online editions of their qualifications but usually for a extensively higher charge than the institutions that specialize in online higher education degree programs.

Reply
Edward Chavez link
27/8/2018 08:29:52 pm

I don't know- why it is taken as a query. Because in my opinion, behavior change is highly significant. I think it is the only missing ingredient in present day's disease prevention. 1)Readiness to change, 2)Barriers to change, 3)Expect relapse- are the three key elements of the amendment. Likewise- pre-contemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, maintenance- are the various stages of change model. You need to take the recommendations of a mentor to get through all the stages of modification successfully.

Reply
Petsforever App link
20/3/2021 01:21:55 pm

Hello
Thanks for sharing this amazing blog. I read it carefully & it was really fantastic. Post some more blogs related to "Best Dog Questions App In Australia "
Regards.

Reply
Deep Cleaning Levittown link
23/8/2022 08:09:57 pm

Veery thoughtful blog

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed

    Author

    Sonya Bevan is an avid dog lover with a Bachelor of Science degree in physiotherapy. This combination lead to seeking science based information on how to teach dogs and she commenced further study to complete a Diploma of Canine Behaviour Science and Technology. Dog training is both a science and an art. When based on solid principles of behavioural science,  teaching also allows creativity when applied to each unique dog. Most of all, it should be fun for both participants and a way to bond with these special animals we love so much.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    June 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2017
    May 2017
    December 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All
    Behaviour Change
    Dog Behaviour
    Dog Body Language
    Dog Etiquette
    Dogs And Us
    Dog Training
    Ethics & Dogs
    Husbandry
    Introducing Dogs To New Experiences
    Puppies
    Scout The Assistance Puppy
    Turbo The Foster Greyhound

Proudly powered by Weebly